You are not using the Solid Coated Pantone Color Swatch. To access this, go up to Window > Color Pallets and then click on the pallet named Solid Coated. You will want to use this pallet. If you already are, then you have Convert Spot Colors to CMYK checked in the print menu. Go to File > Print to the Color Tab. Uncheck the box that says Convert spot colors to CMYK.